Batesville Herald Tribune, Batesville, Indiana

Opinion

September 6, 2013

The American People deserve liberty, safety

The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution protects American citizens from unreasonable searches and seizures. In practice, it requires any search warrant or government surveillance to be judicially sanctioned and supported by probable cause. Unfortunately, recent revelations about the National Security Agency’s (NSA) surveillance activities raise serious questions about whether these constitutional protection are being obeyed.

I am deeply disturbed by disclosures over the past several months that the NSA may be conducting surveillance on American citizens without proper legal authority. Media reports suggest the NSA inappropriately collects records of phone calls made and emails sent by American citizens. Some have claimed the agency has even accessed the content of these communications. Others indicate that the agency has the capacity to monitor 75 percent of all U.S. Internet traffic.

Frankly, most Americans don’t know what to believe.

That is why I recently supported an amendment to prevent the NSA from abusing its counterterrorism powers. The amendment, added to the bill that funds the Department of Defense, will prohibit the NSA from targeting and analyzing the phone calls, emails, and other electronic communications of American citizens. This amendment was adopted instead of a more sweeping one that would have imposed a blanket restriction on the collection and analysis of all bulk data, including data that is known to have prohibited more than 50 terrorist attacks. I could not justify such a sweeping prohibition without further congressional examination of its impact.

The President has acknowledged that the NSA’s powers are “scary to some people.” Yet, he assures us that no rights are being violated. After scandals at the IRS, the Department of Justice and elsewhere, the American People are understandably skeptical.

Clearly, we have more work to do. Congress should draw a bright line between acceptable counterterrorism activities and unacceptable violations of our fundamental rights. We should investigate all allegations against the NSA, re-examine its authorities, and determine the best path forward.

Text Only
Opinion
  • Reader disagrees with senator Reader disagrees with senator Dear Editor, Senator Coats, a recent editorial titled, "Freeing Hoosier job creators," described your Sound Regulation Act. You said, "The bill would require every federal agency to engage in an extensive analysis to d

    April 15, 2014

  • Remembering those who defend our freedom When we send out our presession surveys each year, they generally show that Hoosiers are concerned with issues such as jobs and education, and rightfully so. While veterans' issues may not immediately come to mind as a pressing concern, many people w

    April 15, 2014

  • Moving up economic ladder begins in childhood New national research reveals that America is still a land of opportunity, but many Indiana communities rank poorly in fostering upward economic mobility for children and youth. According to Harvard University's Equality of Opportunity Project, despi

    April 8, 2014

  • Modest achievements for Gov. Pence INDIANAPOLIS - We aren't quite to the halfway point of Gov. Mike Pence's term, but he's now through his second Indiana General Assembly session and this week signed into law the state's first Pre-Kindergarten program, cut the corporate tax, and provi

    April 8, 2014

  • From the mayor Libraries are vital to communities WHEREAS, libraries help lives change in their communities, campuses and schools; WHEREAS, librarians work to meet the changing needs of their communities, including providing resources for everyone and bringing ser

    April 8, 2014

  • Hunters harvest less deer in 2013 It looks as if the 2013 season is coming in as the eighth best season for Indiana deer hunters. Statistics show hunters harvested fewer deer in the 2013 season than in each of the previous five seasons. Hearing the annual tally might be sobering new

    April 1, 2014

  • Salute military youth, too WHEREAS, thousands of brave Americans have demonstrated their courage and commitment to freedom by serving the armed forces of the United States of America in active duty posts in Afghanistan, Iraq and around the world; and WHEREAS, more than 19,000

    March 28, 2014

  • Retired baker grateful to customers Retired baker grateful to customers Dear Editor, Forty-one years ago I had a dream to open a cake shop. My three boys were young so I was only able to do cakes as a hobby. I baked and decorated cakes for 20 years after working a full-time job outsid

    March 25, 2014

  • Many OA high points this year Many OA high points this year Dear Editor, On behalf of the entire Oldenburg Academy family, I wish to say thank you to the Batesville/Oldenburg community, businesses, families, alums and various well-wishers whose support and encouragement meant so

    March 25, 2014

  • Letter to the editor Ziemke out of tune with constituents Dear Editor, In The Herald-Tribune article "Legislators reveal their thoughts on HJR-3" Feb. 21, our legislators revealed the reasoning for their votes on HJR-3, which would have amended the state Constitution to

    March 18, 2014