Batesville Herald Tribune, Batesville, Indiana

Local News

January 20, 2006

Don't mock the turtle soup

Mock turtle soup.

Mention it as nearby as Cincinnati or Shelbyville and you may get a questionable look. For reasons lost over the last century, the soup that's been sold at church festivals and other functions in the greater Batesville area for generations is virtually unknown in other parts of the region.

Pat Schrank, who helps make the hearty meal for the annual Holy Family Catholic Church fund-raiser, has a theory that an early settler came through New Orleans before moving to the area and brought the Cajun-style recipe along.

The gourmet soup, using real turtle, is still on menus in fine dining restaurants in the Big Easy.

The item was also popular in Victorian England (it is mentioned in "Alice in Wonderland") and also Germany, according to Mary Gehring of Phi Beta Psi sorority. The time-consuming process involved in making the thick "spicy vegetable soup," as Schrank calls it, takes place annually at Catholic church festivals in Sunman (St. Nicholas, June); Morris (St. Anthony, early September); Batesville, (St. Louis, mid-September); and Oldenburg, (Holy Family, early October); as well as at the century-old Napoleon Firemen's Festival in late July.

Other churches and groups get in on the act as well. Phi Beta Psi and Holy Family make it in January for fund-raisers. The big cooking pots will be heating up next week (see Activities on pages 6-7 for details).

Gehring says the sorority has been making the popular fare since perhaps before the early 1970s. From her research, she found that farm families in the area would typically make the soup around butchering time. Many old recipes called for cooking a cow's head and tail for the meat. Some families would use beef brains and the heart or other meat and grind it up. "It was a cleanup soup," according to Gehring. (See a typical area recipe in the box.)

Text Only
Local News
  • Brother charged in shooting

    July 23, 2014

  • Apartments tax abatement approved After gaining a recommendation from the Batesville Economic Development Commission, developer Bruce Rippe was at the Batesville City Council meeting July 14 to request a 10-year real property tax abatement for Depot Square, which will be 45 one- and

    July 22, 2014

  • Readers' input will guide newspaper staff “What newspapers do you read? What Web sites do you visit? Where do you shop? How do you use our newspaper and our Web site?” wonders Laura Welborn, publisher of The Herald-Tribune, Batesville; Daily News, Greensburg; and Rushville Republican.Answers

    July 22, 2014

  • nws - bv072214 - BPRB Batesville Parks and Recreation Board brainstorms new funding Batesville Parks and Recreation Board members brainstormed different ways to offset budget cuts and increasing demands across several projects at the July 16 meeting.Funding first came up in the meeting as Eric Frey, Administrative Resources associat

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • nws - bv072214 - RCCF impact grant $25,000 community impact grant awarded From a pool off 11 applicants, the Ripley County Safe Schools Commission Safe School Readiness project was chosen to receive the $25,000 Ripley County Community Foundation Community Impact Grant. It will provide each public school district in Ripley

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • lowery, snyder gesture.jpg Local 'servant-leader' is new Ivy Tech chancellor

    COLUMBUS – Batesville resident Chris Lowery has been selected to serve as Ivy Tech Community College Columbus/Southeast chancellor.


    July 18, 2014 2 Photos

  • nws - bv071814 - Williams, John Williams will serve as interim superintendent ST. LEON – Sunman-Dearborn Community School Corp. trustees will soon begin the process of looking for a new superintendent since Dr. Jeff Hendrix resigned at the end of June to take another position.On July 10, President Jeff Lyness reported, “We’ll

    July 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • nws - bv071814 - BCC boofest Boo Fest will creep here

    As volunteer directors Mary Ellen Rippe and Bill Flannery prepare for Fear Factory’s fourth season, they have “identified some tremendous assets in our community and formed an idea that, if we all work together, we can exploit the opportunity for all

    July 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • nws - bv071814 - Fields, Tricia Author offers advice about writing BROOKVILLE – About a dozen persons participated in a writing workshop at the Brookville Library July 1. The three-hour seminar was led by Tricia Fields, author of “The Territory,” “Scratchgravel Road” and “Wrecked.” She began by saying, “Each one of

    July 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • nws - bv071814 - 4-H logo A lot of bull(s) A daring grandstand event will debut at the Ripley County 4-H Fair, which takes place July 20-26 at the Osgood fairgrounds. “We’re doing a rodeo” Wednesday at 7 p.m., presented by Fox Hollow Rodeo, Waynesville, Ohio, announces Katie Johnson, Purdue U

    July 18, 2014 1 Photo