Batesville Herald Tribune, Batesville, Indiana

Local News

November 1, 2013

Turkey dinner going strong at 50 years


They debated which were the worst jobs. Smith nominated making the slaw because of the pervasive odor. “We grew the cabbages in our garden” to make slaw for 400. Les Smith would walk in the kitchen and say, “I hate this smell.”

Hartshorn disliked “taking the innards out of the turkeys,” which used to be picked up very early Friday morning in a semi-thawed condition. Flory had a crew of male retirees (Hartshorn, Smith, Glen Butte and more) who had to run warm water over the birds and pull the frosty gizzards, necks and other parts out.

Hartshorn recalls two near disasters. About two decades ago, they ran out of turkeys about 6 p.m. “We had a lot more people show up” than expected and perhaps carryout portions were too generous. “We made a quick call to Kroger. Kroger sliced ham. We immediately jumped in the car, zoomed over,” and grabbed the substitute meat. “Lo and behold, we had left the car running with the keys in it and the doors locked.” Rapidly summoned policeman Bill Dramann and a coat hanger saved the day. “People were disappointed it wasn’t turkey, but at least they had something.”

Likewise, at least 10 years ago, the turkey vanished before the ending hour. Nettnay says they bought every rotisserie chicken Kroger had. Most pieces were served to church members, who eat together after public diners leave.

The dinner “almost died out about eight years ago” due to lack of leadership. Longtime couples “were burned out. It’s a big job,” Nettnay says.

The fundraiser has evolved, going from a home to church operation. With stricter state health department rules, Judi Craig became a certified food handler and instructed other members about how to keep the meals safe.

According to Smith, “I ran around many times trying to find the best price for turkeys,” switching between Kroger, Crum turkey farm and the former Batesville IGA. For the last six years, boneless turkeys have been purchased from Kopps, Harrison, Ohio.

Text Only
Local News
  • Dollar General scammed out of dollars

    The Batesville Police Department is currently investigating a theft that occurred July 24 at the Batesville Dollar General store.

    August 1, 2014

  • Where is this Toyota?

    August 1, 2014

  • BCEF sponsors 3K, 5K and 12K races "The Batesville Community Education Foundation will be hosting the Batesville K12 again this year, but it will be a little different," reports foundation administrator Kelly Poltrack. The athletic event is slated for Saturday, Sept 27, in conjunction

    August 1, 2014

  • Everyone in the pool! Splish! Splash! Get ready for a nine-hour nonstop open air party.Th city-sponsored Back to School Bash at the Batesville Memorial Pool will take place Friday, Aug. 8, from 3 p.m.-midnight, reports manager Elizabeth Hall. “We wanted to do something fu

    August 1, 2014

  • Sewer rate increase eyed Batesville clerk-treasurer Ron Weigel told Batesville Board of Works members during a special July 29 meeting that the city has had to push off a number of sewer projects over the past couple of years “because we weren’t rate adequate” since about 20

    August 1, 2014

  • nws - bv080114 - bicentennial Big plans for Indiana's 200th birthday Indiana’s official 200th birthday is Dec. 11, 2016, but individuals and groups across the state are now preparing for the event. Perry Hammock, Indiana Bicentennial Commission executive director, and René Stanley, the commission’s community resources

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • nws - bv080114 - works of mercy People show faith in Works of Mercy BROOKVILLE – Jennifer and Michael Wiesemann took the leap of faith and bought the former Elsie Dreyer Nursing Home building at 273 Main St., Brookville, and established the Works of Mercy Center, which will provide free help to people in need. Wiesem

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Five new cars and trailer burn on interstate Six Batesville firefighters responded to a car-carrier truck fire on westbound Interstate 74 just behind Batesville High School at 11:25 a.m. Sunday, July 27, according to Fire Chief Todd Schutte. The chief also called for tanker support from Oldenbu

    July 29, 2014

  • nws - bv072914 - cincinnati orchestra Symphony highlights arts council's 25th anniversary The Franklin County Arts Council, currently celebrating its 25th anniversary, was established when Franklin County High School opened in Brookville.Vice President Patti Wilhelm, Brookville, who has been involved with the organization for 24 years, re

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • nws - bv072914 chinese classroom Educators work and play in China ”I loved China!” raves Batesville Middle School language arts and special education teacher Alex Davis, who worked in Beijing with five other Batesville Community School Corp. educators June 28-July 18 to sharpen the English skills of Chinese incomin

    July 29, 2014 2 Photos